Consumer Today's is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

The 5 Best Gutter Guards in 2022

AI Consumer Report Team
  Aug 14, 2022 10:34 AM

Clogged gutters can be a headache, especially once the rainy season starts!

One of the easiest solutions is to use a gutter guard! It catches debris that falls on the gutter, which prevents ice dams, clogs, and roof damage, among others.

When your gutters are in tip-top shape, you will perform less maintenance work. It also keeps your house safe and comfortable.

Are you looking for the best gutter guards consumer reports? Keep on reading and we’ll let you know the top options to consider.


Compare Products

Showing  1 - 5  in  5 results
1
  • SCORE
    9.5
    AI Score

    CTs Score is our evaluation score, from 0 to 10 based on the data our tool collects. This score is assessed by our team of experts, not influenced by any individual or organization. Learn more

  • Brand
    A-M Gutter Guard
2
  • SCORE
    9.4
    AI Score

    CTs Score is our evaluation score, from 0 to 10 based on the data our tool collects. This score is assessed by our team of experts, not influenced by any individual or organization. Learn more

  • Brand
    FLEXXPOINT
3
  • SCORE
    9.3
    AI Score

    CTs Score is our evaluation score, from 0 to 10 based on the data our tool collects. This score is assessed by our team of experts, not influenced by any individual or organization. Learn more

  • Brand
    THE GUTTERBRUSH SIMPLE GUTTER GUARD
4
  • SCORE
    9.2
    AI Score

    CTs Score is our evaluation score, from 0 to 10 based on the data our tool collects. This score is assessed by our team of experts, not influenced by any individual or organization. Learn more

  • Brand
    GUTTERSTUFF
5
  • SCORE
    9.1
    AI Score

    CTs Score is our evaluation score, from 0 to 10 based on the data our tool collects. This score is assessed by our team of experts, not influenced by any individual or organization. Learn more

  • Brand
    E-Z-GUTTER GUARD

Last update on 2022-08-14 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API


Top Picks

Below are the top products that should be on your radar. We’ll also talk about the notable features that make them stand out.

1. A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard

It might be more expensive than most of the products included in our recommendations, but that should not be an issue. The difference lies on the design and the materials, so you can be confident that it is worth every dollar.

One thing that we love in this product is how the design is non-obtrusive. This is hardly noticeable when you are looking from the ground.

The heavy-gauge construction is one more thing that makes it exceptional. It is made of 100% aluminum, which makes it rust-resistant.

Because of the strength of the aluminum that is used in this gutter guard, it can handle even heavy downpour. This is unlike other materials that can easily deform.

The patented design is also one feature that makes it perform better than its competitors. It improves air flow from the top to the bottom, which makes it easier to get rid of the debris stuck in your gutter.

The unique bubble design is also one of the highlights of this gutter guard. With the latter, it remains free-flowing. This makes sure that only water will get in your gutter and there will be no debris.

Pros:

  • Durable
  • Handles heavy downpours
  • Easy to install

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Can be too wide for some

2. FlexxPoint 30-Year Gutter Cover System

This gutter guard is from a small and family-owned business. The company takes pride in their attention to detail, making sure that every product is evident of premium quality.

It is well-loved by many because of the fine mesh. This blocks debris to prevent the gutter from clogging. Nonetheless, there are still small particles that can get through.

When you purchase this gutter guard, it is already packaged with stainless steel fastener. This helps to make the installation a breeze to accomplish.

For versatility, there are eight sizes that are available, so you can choose which one is most suitable for your gutter.

It is available in a variety of colors, which include black, white, and matte aluminum. You can choose which one is most suitable for the design and color of your roof.

Best of all, this is an affordable gutter guard. This proves that you don’t have to spend a fortune to enjoy excellent quality.

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Affordable
  • Available in a variety of sizes

Cons:

  • Not good in snow
  • Made of light gauge material

3. Gutter Brush Leaf Guard for Standard 5-inch Rain Gutters

This is a simple and affordable alternative compared to the traditional designs of the gutter guards you will find in the market. It does not rely on mesh or screen. Rather, the brush has bristles that prevent leaves and debris from getting in the gutter.

It is also a great choice if you don’t want to go through the hassle of complicated installation. You won’t need any tools. All that you need to do is to set the brush in the gutter and let it do its magic. You can just fold the brush to customize its length. There’s no need to cut it.

In terms of construction, the bristles of the brush are made of double UV-protected polypropylene. The wire core, on the other hand, is 12-gauge galvanized steel.

When it comes to cleaning, you also don’t need to exert a lot of effort. The spikes can easily attract leaves and debris, so it is important that you clean it regularly. Just remove the brush, shake, and remove by hand any debris that remains. Slide it back in the gutter.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Easy to use
  • Labor-saving

Cons:

  • Can easily attract mosquitoes
  • Leaves can get stuck in the spikes  

4. GUTTERSTUFF EZ Gutter Guard

If you are looking for a gutter guard for a DIY installation, this is the perfect choice for you.

This product is in the form of a gutter filter insert. It does not have a screen or mesh surface that filters leaves and debris.

It comes with a patented flat-bottom gutter foam. The foam absorbs water and let it flow out of the gutter. On the other hand, the upper surface filters dirt.

The manufacturer also claims that this will prevent standing water in the gutter. This means that there will be no mosquitoes.

We also love how it offers no-show protection. Once installed properly, the foam is hidden from sight, which prevents it from ruining the look of your roof.

Because it is a foam, there are some who would question its durability. Unfortunately, there are many negative reviews about how it seems to easily lose its shape through the years, especially if it frequently gets wet.

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Good warranty coverage
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Filters can break down due to extreme heat
  • Can shrink over time

5. E-Z-Gutter Guard EZ-Quick-10 Gutter Guard

This is another gutter guard that you will love in terms of ease of installation. The problem is that it needs trimming depending on the width of your gutter. However, the good thing is that there’s no need for screws to snap it on the gutter.

Aluminum is the main material used in this gutter mesh guard. It is rust-resistant. There is also no plastic component that can collapse due to extreme weather conditions. The painted aluminum will not also be damaged by the heat of the sun.

It has a tension-engineered construction. Because of the latter, it snaps on the hinge properly. This is unlike others that can easily be blown by wind or deformed by rain.

Pros:

  • Rust-resistant
  • Withstands rough weather
  • No need for screws

Cons:

  • Not for heavy snow
  • Trimming can be tricky

Types of Gutter Guards

Before we round up our suggestions, let’s first have a quick look at the types of gutter guards available on the market.

Screens

If leaves are your main problem, a screen gutter guard will be a great choice. However, this may not work on pine needles and seeds because of the large opening.

Ease of installation is one of its best assets. Depending on the type of the screen, you can just slide it under the shingles. There is no need for fastening.

This is also a great option if you are looking for an economical gutter guard. The average cost is only $.10 to $2 per foot.

Surface Tension

One of its unique characteristics is the rounded edges. Leaves and debris will also fall on the edges.

In some instances, this may require you to re-hang the existing gutter. The best installation is to follow the angle of the roof.

However, take note that this is the most expensive from all the gutter types. On average, the price will be anywhere from $3 to $6 per foot.

Fine Mesh

They work like the screen gutter guards, but the openings are smaller. This allows it to deliver a better job at filtering debris, even seeds.

A common problem with this gutter guard is the main material used. It is made of window-type screen. This can be easily damaged by big branches or ice.

We also love how it requires minimal maintenance. Because of the ability to filter out debris, you won’t need to always clean your gutter.

Reverse Curve

This is exactly what the name implies. It is in a reverse curve, which means that it positions water downward. In the same way, it directs the leaves and debris to the ground so that it won’t get stuck in the gutter.

While it is promising, there are also some issues with reverse curve gutters. It easily gets dirty, so it will require quite an effort when it comes to care and maintenance. It will slow down the flow of water once the leaves start to accumulate.

Foam

These guards are not installed on the top of the gutter. Rather, this fits directly into the gutter. This is made of foam, so it is easy to fit and it follows the shape of the gutter.

The material is porous. It allows the foam to absorb water that flows in the gutter. This means that leaves and debris will not get inside, which will prevent clogging.


Buying Guides

To help you narrow down the options, below are the most important factors to consider.

Ease of Use

One of the most important is to choose a gutter guard that is effortless to install. Most of the time, there’s no need to hire someone to do the installation for you. This can be an easy DIY task.

In most of the products mentioned above, there is no need to use any tool. There are even products that won’t require screws to snap them on the gutter.

More than being easy to use, you should also look for one that is effortless when it comes to care and maintenance. Otherwise, this can give you a headache and will clog the gutter.

Durability

Consider the main material that gutter guard uses. This will have a direct impact on durability, effectiveness, and overall performance.

Aluminum is a common material in gutter guards. It is rust-resistant, so you can expect it to withstand many years of use.

Stainless steel is also a common material that you will find in gutter guards. This is cheaper than aluminum. However, this is not as exceptional when it comes to durability.

In the case of cheaper gutter guards, plastic is a common material of choice. While it is affordable, it is not as durable as those that are made of aluminum or stainless steel.

There are some styles of gutter guards that are made of foam or brush bristles. Regardless, make sure that they won’t easily break down, especially because of the heat of the sun.

It must also be durable against animals. Choose a material strong enough to have an assurance that they cannot be easily damaged by birds and animals that can reside on the roof.

Compatibility

Before you start looking for gutter guards, start with an evaluation of the gutter that you have at home. Pick one that is suitable for it, especially in terms of the length and width. If it isn’t compatible with the gutter that you have, it will only be a waste of money.

Speaking of compatibility, it should look good when it blends with your roof. It is good to choose a gutter guard that is non-obtrusive so that you won’t see it from the ground. Choose colors and patterns that will not ruin the look of your roof.

Care and Maintenance

There is no type of gutter-guard that is maintenance-free. Even the best ones will require effort to clean, although, you don’t have to do it often. Look for gutter guards that won’t need frequent cleaning. Despite this, make sure that the effectiveness is not compromised in any way.

Warranty

This is one thing that can provide you peace of mind. Most manufacturers will offer a one-year warranty. You can expect support from them if the gutter guard becomes defective within the warranty period.


Conclusion

Stop leaves and debris from clogging your gutter! Now is the time to invest in the best gutter guards, including our recommendations above.

Gone were the days when cleaning the gutter needs to be a messy and stinky task.

Do you have other products to add to our list? Any tips you would like to share? Feel free to leave a comment below.


4
1 ratings